A no-nonsense VPN comparison: audits, kill switch, split tunneling, and travel ready picks without the tech fluff.

I was on a refinery shutdown a few years back working swing shifts, with cold coffee, and spotty motel WiFi. I went to pay a bill on my laptop, and the page loaded in a language I couldn’t read. That’s when I realized two things: (1) public WiFi is like free donuts in the break room great until you wonder who touched them; and (2) a good VPN is the lockout/tagout for your internet life.
If you work hard, keep your head down, and just want tools that work without drama, this rundown is for you. Straight talk. No fluff. Let’s compare the 10 VPNs that actually earn their keep.
What matters (and how I judged)
- No-logs policy with independent audit (trust > marketing)
- Kill switch (like a breaker: if the tunnel drops, your traffic doesn’t)
- Split tunneling (send some apps through the VPN, others direct)
- Works well for travel (many countries, reliable connections)
- Beginner-friendly (clear apps, simple setup)
- Honest pricing / device limits
I link to credible sources for audits and features so you don’t have to take my word for it.
The Short List: 10 VPNs I’d actually recommend
1) ExpressVPN — Polished, reliable, great for travel
- Why it stands out: Consistent connections and a strong reputation. “Network Lock” kill switch and split tunneling on key platforms. Audited tech (TrustedServer/Lightway). TunnelBear: Secure VPN Servicesecuritum.com
2) NordVPN — Big feature set, serious audits
- Why it stands out: Deloitte-audited no-logs claims; strong kill switch; split tunneling options on major OSes. Good all-around choice. NordVPN
3) Surfshark — Unlimited devices, budget-friendly
- Why it stands out: One account for the whole household. Deloitte audit for no-logs. Split tunneling (“Bypasser”) on supported platforms. Private Internet Access
4) Proton VPN — Privacy-first, open-source apps
- Why it stands out: Independent security audits (Securitum). Excellent kill switch and split tunneling where supported. Solid free plan for light use.
5) Mullvad — Anonymous by design
- Why it stands out: No email required; can pay with cash; multiple third-party audits. Great for folks who want as little paper trail as possible. Mullvad VPN+2Mullvad VPN+2
6) IVPN — Small, serious, transparent
- Why it stands out: Cure53 audits on infrastructure; split tunneling well documented; “firewall” acts as a robust leak stop. For people who like reading changelogs. IVPN+2IVPN+2
7) Private Internet Access (PIA) — Feature-rich, proven at scale
- Why it stands out: Deloitte audits; excellent split tunneling across desktop OSes; long track record. Private Internet Access+1PIA Support
8) CyberGhost — Easy apps, friendly pricing
- Why it stands out: Deloitte audited no-logs; split tunneling (“exceptions”) on Windows/Android. Good for streaming and simple, routine protection.
9) TunnelBear — Beginner-friendly (and actually audited)
- Why it stands out: Annual security audits (Cure53). Cute bear theme, but the tech is serious. Split tunneling mostly on Android (“SplitBear”).
10) Windscribe — Generous free tier, power features
- Why it stands out: “Firewall” is a proactive kill switch; split tunneling on supported platforms. A solid budget/free option for casual use.
VPN comparison: no-logs policy (independent audit)
- Audited providers to put on your shortlist:
ExpressVPN, NordVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN, Mullvad, IVPN, PIA, CyberGhost, TunnelBear (annual). Each has published independent audits of core tech, apps, or infrastructure. That matters more than any ad banner.
Blue-collar translation: If a company invites outside pros to poke holes in their setup and then posts the results, that’s like letting OSHA on the shop floor you respect it.
Best VPN kill switch feature comparison
- Always-on/strong implementations:
- Mullvad (enforced firewall-style blocking)
- ExpressVPN (“Network Lock”)
- Proton VPN (Permanent Kill Switch)
- IVPN (App firewall + SOCKS5 tricks for app level failsafe)
- Windscribe (proactive “Firewall”)
Why you care: If the tunnel drops while you’re on hotel Wi-Fi, the kill switch keeps your real IP from “peeking out” like a glove with a hole in the finger.
VPN comparison: split tunneling feature
Want Spotify to go direct while your browser stays protected? Split tunneling is your friend.
- Broadest split tunneling support across desktop OSes: PIA. PIA Support
- Strong, well-documented split tunneling: ExpressVPN, Surfshark (“Bypasser”), Proton VPN, Mullvad, IVPN. TunnelBear: Secure VPN ServiceExpressVPNSurfshark+1IVPN
- Android only split tunneling: TunnelBear (SplitBear). Mullvad VPN
- Supported on key platforms: Windscribe (Windows/Mac/Android).
Best VPN for travel (multiple countries)
When you’re bouncing between job sites or just taking that long overdue vacation you want coverage and reliability.
- Top picks for travel: ExpressVPN, NordVPN, Surfshark, PIA, CyberGhost. Big networks, stable apps, and good track records in places with cranky internet. (See each provider’s network and platform support pages before you go.) TunnelBear: Secure VPN ServiceNordVPN SupportPrivate Internet Access+1Windscribe
Tip: Download apps and log in before you travel. Some countries’ app stores get weird.
VPN comparison for anonymous browsing
If you want the least paper trail possible:
- Mullvad: No email required; can pay cash; strong audits. Mullvad VPN+2Mullvad VPN+2
- IVPN: Transparent team, Cure53 audits, tight firewall defaults. IVPN+1
- Proton VPN: Open-source clients, audited, privacy ethos.
Reality check: A VPN hides your IP and encrypts traffic. It doesn’t make you invisible if you’re logged into accounts that know you by name.
VPN for beginners: easy-to-use comparison
- Easiest UIs: TunnelBear, ExpressVPN, CyberGhost (big buttons, simple defaults). ExpressVPNTunnelBear: Secure VPN ServiceWindscribe
- Best free start: Proton VPN (limited but usable).
- Best “set it and forget it” privacy: Mullvad (opinionated defaults). Mullvad VPN
Quick picks (so you can get on with your day)
- All-around best: NordVPN or ExpressVPN
- Budget with muscle: Surfshark or PIA
- Privacy-hardcore: Mullvad or IVPN
- Beginner-friendly: TunnelBear or CyberGhost
- Free starter: Proton VPN
- Free/budget tinkerers: Windscribe
A working person’s wrap-up
Look most of us don’t have time to babysit our gadgets. We need tools that work when the WiFi is sketchy, the schedule’s tight, and the stakes (like your banking info) are high. Pick one from the top row, turn on the kill switch, set split tunneling how you like it, and get back to living your life. A good VPN isn’t fancy. It’s just another piece of PPE only for your data.